new evidence for event horizons surrounding black holes

Top: Gas from the companion star is drawn by gravity onto the black hole in a swirling pattern. As the gas nears the event horizon, a strong gravitational redshift makes it appear redder and dimmer. When the gas finally crosses the event horizon, it disappears from view. Because of this, the region within the event horizon appears black.

Bottom: As above, gas from the companion star flows down onto the collapsed star — in this case a neutron star instead of a black hole. As the gas approaches the neutron star, a similar gravitational redshift makes the gas appear redder and dimmer. However, when the gas strikes the solid surface of the neutron star, it glows brightly.

On Rationality

  1. It is important to distinguish rationality from logic. Being ‘logical’ can still lead to unreasonable results! At the beginning of the age of modern science, Francis Bacon  (1561-1626) wrote about this. See also  Bacon and Scholasticism
  2. Computer literacy challenges information literacy. In computer science, we have to worry about “what computes,” not just what pleases our presuppositions about the logic of things. This is what Bacon means when he talks about the Idols that give us false understanding.
  3. The notion of the illusion in things is central to human understanding. In the great Hindu classic, the Bhagavad Gita, we hear Arjuna say (Chapter II)
    He who attendeth to the inclinations of the senses, in them hath a concern; from this concern is created passion, from passion anger, from anger is produced delusion, from delusion a loss of the memory, from the loss of memory loss of discrimination, and from loss of discrimination loss of all! But he who, free from attachment or repulsion for objects, experienceth them through the senses and organs, with his heart obedient to his will, attains to tranquillity of thought.
  4. The ‘New Economy’ generated by the computer revolution challenges the conventional notion of ‘rationality’ from modern times. Computer firms get names like Syntax, Inc., in honor of how grammar has become newly important. Instead of dismissing ‘computer nerds’ as eccentric & socially limited people, now we must engage the fact that it is they who have the money.
  5. This is not to say that now “everything goes,” far from it. But is to say that rationalities like the DSM-IV Diagnostic & Statistical Manual which categorizes disorders according to a ‘logical’ scheme are suspect. The hackers & visionaries of the Silicon Valley are falling back from the consensus of the 17th century on the nature of reason. We are led back to a re-examination of the world-view of the Renaissance humanists.

“Wovon man nicht sprechen kann,
darüber muß man schweigen.”

“Whereof one cannot speak,
wherefore must one remain silent.”

—Ludwig Wittgenstein, Tractatus logico-philosophicus, 1921